Should I Consolidate My Student Loans? 11 Questions to Answer First

If you’re feeling overwhelmed by multiple loans, servicers, and due dates, consolidation might sound like a simple fix—and in many cases, it can be. You might get a longer repayment term, a lower monthly payment, or just one bill to keep track of instead of several.

But consolidation isn’t the right move for everyone. Before you jump in, it’s worth asking a few key questions to make sure it fits your situation and goals. Let’s walk through what to consider.

Table of Contents

1. 1. Why am I thinking about consolidating in the first place?
2. 2. Should I consolidate federal vs. private loans?
   1. Should I consolidate my federal student loans?
   2. Should I consolidate my private student loans?
3. 3. When should I consolidate student loans?
4. 4. Will consolidating simplify my payments?
5. 5. Will consolidating reduce my monthly payment?
6. 6. Should I consolidate student loans if I want to change my loan terms?
7. 7. How will consolidating affect my federal repayment benefits?
8. 8. Should I consolidate my student loans for PSLF?
9. 9. Should I consolidate all my student loans—or just some?
10. 10. Should I refinance instead of consolidate?
11. 11. Will consolidation benefit me now—and in the future?

1. Why am I thinking about consolidating in the first place?

Before you consolidate, take a moment to assess your situation.

• What kinds of loans do you have, federal or private?
• What are your current interest rates, payments, and loan servicers?
• And most importantly—what’s your goal? Are you looking for lower monthly payments, simpler repayment, forgiveness, or just a fresh start?

Knowing what you want to achieve will help you figure out if consolidation is the right move.

2. Should I consolidate federal vs. private loans?

The kind of loans you have will determine whether consolidation or refinancing is even an option—and what benefits or trade-offs come with it.

Should I consolidate my federal student loans?

If you have federal loans, you can consolidate them through a Direct Consolidation Loan from the Department of Education. This combines your loans into one and keeps you eligible for federal student loan repayment plans and forgiveness programs. It won’t lower your interest rate, but it can simplify your payments and open the door to more repayment options.

Should I consolidate my private student loans?

Private loans aren’t eligible for federal consolidation. If you want to combine private loans—or a mix of private and federal—you’d need to refinance through a private lender. Refinancing may offer a lower interest rate, but it also means giving up federal benefits like income-driven repayment and loan forgiveness. Be careful before refinancing federal loans, especially if you rely on those protections.

Read More

Is It Ever a Good Idea to Refinance Federal Student Loans?

3. When should I consolidate student loans?

Timing your consolidation can make a real difference. If you’re close to qualifying for loan forgiveness or already making progress on an income-driven plan, it might make sense to wait—consolidating could restart the clock in some cases. But if you’re just starting repayment, have loans in default, or want to simplify things early on, consolidating sooner could be a smart move.

It also depends on what you need right now. If your monthly payments feel unmanageable and you’re looking for some breathing room, consolidation might help. Just make sure the timing lines up with your bigger goals, not just what feels easiest in the moment.

4. Will consolidating simplify my payments?

Usually, yes. If you’ve got multiple federal loans with different servicers and due dates, consolidation rolls them into one loan with one monthly payment. That can make your repayment feel way more manageable. But if all your loans are already with the same servicer or on autopay, the difference might be more about peace of mind than actual convenience.

Refinancing also simplifies your payments by replacing multiple loans—federal, private, or both—with a single new loan from a private lender.

5. Will consolidating reduce my monthly payment?

It can, but there’s a catch. Consolidating your federal loans might lower your monthly payment by giving you a longer repayment term—sometimes up to 30 years. That can make things more affordable month to month, but you’ll likely pay more in interest over time.

With a Direct Consolidation Loan, your new interest rate isn’t based on your credit score—it’s the weighted average of your existing federal loan rates, rounded up to the nearest one-eighth of a percent. This means your rate on the new loan won’t go up or down—it’ll stay about the same.

Refinancing works differently. If you qualify with a private lender—usually based on your credit, income, and debt—you might get a lower interest rate, which can reduce both your monthly payment and the total interest you pay. But because you lose key benefits when you refinance federal loans, it’s a tradeoff worth examining carefully.

Read More

How Does Student Loan Interest Work?

6. Should I consolidate student loans if I want to change my loan terms?

If your goal is to change your repayment terms—like lowering your monthly payment or extending your timeline—consolidation might help. When you consolidate federal loans, they’re replaced with a new Direct Consolidation Loan that comes with a new repayment term, typically between 10 and 30 years. A longer term can reduce your monthly payment, but you’ll likely pay more interest overall.

Refinancing also gives you a new loan with new terms, but through a private lender. It usually offers more flexibility, letting you choose a shorter or longer repayment term based on your goals. Just keep in mind that refinancing federal loans means giving up federal protections and benefits.

7. How will consolidating affect my federal repayment benefits?

Consolidating your federal loans can help you access certain repayment plans or forgiveness programs—but it can also cause you to lose progress you’ve already made. For example, if you’re working toward Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) or income-driven repayment (IDR) forgiveness, consolidation can reset the clock, meaning your previous qualifying payments may no longer count. (Right now, a one-time adjustment from the Department of Education may preserve that progress—but that won’t always be the case.)

You could also lose specific benefits tied to the original loans. For instance, some loans qualify for interest subsidies during deferment or come with a grace period after graduation. When you consolidate, those perks go away because you’re essentially starting fresh with a new loan.

And if you refinance through a private lender instead of consolidating through the government, you’ll lose all federal benefits—including access to IDR plans, PSLF, and future forbearance or forgiveness opportunities. So it’s important to weigh what you might be giving up.

8. Should I consolidate my student loans for PSLF?

It depends on what kind of loans you have. If you have FFEL or Perkins loans, they’re not eligible for Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) unless you consolidate them into a Direct Consolidation Loan. So in that case, yes—consolidating is a necessary step to qualify.

But if you already have Direct Loans and you’ve been making qualifying payments toward PSLF, consolidating could actually set you back. A new consolidation loan means starting over at zero qualifying payments, unless there’s a temporary waiver or adjustment in place (like the one-time IDR account adjustment, which helps some borrowers keep their progress).

So before you consolidate for PSLF, make sure you know which loan types you have and where you stand in the forgiveness process. It can help—or hurt—depending on the timing.

9. Should I consolidate all my student loans—or just some?

You don’t have to consolidate everything—you can pick and choose which federal loans to include. This can be helpful if you’ve already made progress toward forgiveness or income-driven repayment on certain loans and don’t want to reset that progress.

With refinancing, you also get to choose which loans to include. You don’t have to refinance your federal loans—many people refinance only their private loans to try for a lower rate, while keeping their federal loans untouched to preserve benefits.

10. Should I refinance instead of consolidate?

It depends on your loan types and your goals. Consolidation is a federal process that only applies to federal loans—it won’t lower your interest rate, but it can simplify repayment and help you qualify for certain plans or forgiveness programs.

Refinancing, on the other hand, can include federal, private, or both types of loans. It may lower your interest rate and change your repayment term to one that’s most favorable to you. If you don’t need the benefits federal loans provide, it can be worthwhile to consider.

One way to explore the rates you could get via refinancing is to use a marketplace like Credible, where you can prequalify without impacting your credit, and get a glimpse at the rates you might qualify for if you refinance.

Read More

The Pros and Cons of Refinancing Student Loans and Refinancing vs. Consolidating Student Loans

If the interest rate and terms to refinance are not better than the current loans, I don’t recommend refinancing. Instead focus on potentially consolidating for simplicity, but only if it provides an economic benefit.

Erin Kinkade, CFP®

11. Will consolidation benefit me now—and in the future?

This is the big-picture question—and now you have the tools to answer it. Look back at what you learned: Are your loans federal, and could consolidation open up access to better repayment options or forgiveness? Would a longer repayment term ease your monthly budget, or would it just stretch out your debt?

If your main goal is simplicity, or you’re trying to fix issues like default or ineligibility for PSLF, consolidation might make sense. But if you’re already making steady progress—or would lose important benefits—it might not be worth it. Use your answers to the earlier questions as a filter: if consolidation checks more “pro” boxes than “con,” it could be the right next step.

Read More

Pros and Cons of Consolidating Student Loans