To compare auto insurance companies, focus on customer review ratings, discounts, and premium prices. Amica, Travelers, Farmers, The Hartford, GEICO, Nationwide, Esurance, and Allstate are our picks for the top car insurers of 2019.

Our research, news, ratings, and assessments are scrutinized using strict editorial integrity. Our editorial staff does not receive direction from advertisers on our website or our Partnerships Team. Our company may receive compensation from partners seen on our website. Here's how we make money.