How to Convert an IRA to a Gold IRA Without Penalty

Converting an individual retirement account (IRA) to a gold IRA is a good way to diversify your portfolio. Gold is a tangible asset that has historically held its value. Going from a traditional IRA or Roth IRA to a gold IRA can be as easy as transferring the funds over, but there are some rules to follow. 

Here, we’ll cover the steps to convert an IRA to a gold IRA without penalty. 

What are IRA penalties?

IRAs are a popular way to invest in retirement, but they come with rules that can lead to penalties if they aren’t followed correctly. These rules are in place to ensure that the funds are used for their intended purpose—retirement. 

The main difference between a gold IRA and a traditional or Roth IRA is the type of investment each account holds. Traditional or Roth IRAs usually hold stocks and mutual funds, while gold IRAs invest in physical gold and other pure metals. This impacts how the accounts are managed and the rules they are bound by. 

The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) assesses penalties on IRAs based on contributions and withdrawals. They are meant to prevent early withdrawal and misuse of funds. These penalties also protect tax advantages and prevent exploits. 

Penalties to avoid

One of the most common IRA penalties is for early withdrawal. If you withdraw your IRA funds before you’re 59.5 years old, you face a 10% early withdrawal penalty in addition to income tax. This is easily avoidable by simply using other sources of income before your retirement instead of withdrawing. 

There are two ways you can move funds from one IRA to another without incurring an early withdrawal penalty:

1. A direct transfer moves your funds from one institution to another without penalty.
2. A trustee-to-trustee rollover lets you take the funds from one account and hold onto them for up to 60 days before it’s considered taxable and subject to penalties. 

According to the IRS, you are only allowed one rollover per year. However, this doesn’t apply to traditional IRA to Roth IRA rollovers. Multiple rollovers in a year are subject to a 10% early withdrawal tax. 

Am I eligible for a penalty-free gold IRA conversion? 

Certain retirement accounts are eligible for a penalty-free gold IRA conversion. Employer-sponsored retirement accounts, like a 401(k), or an individual account, like a Roth IRA, are eligible for penalty-free direct rollovers. 

Tax shelter accounts, such as 403(b) annuities, 457, pension plans, or Thrift Savings Plans (TSP), are also eligible for a gold IRA rollover. 

How do I convert my IRA to gold without penalty?

Here is a step-by-step guide to converting your IRA to a gold IRA without penalty:

1. Open a gold IRA: Open a self-directed gold IRA or Roth gold IRA with a reputable company.

2. Contact your IRA admin: Inform your current IRA admin that you intend to transfer funds to a gold IRA.

3. Fill out the paperwork: Fill out the forms for your new gold IRA and include the amount you will transfer.

4. Wait for the transfer: Your current IRA admin will transfer funds to your new gold IRA account. 

5. Select your metals: Choose which coins and metals you will hold in your gold IRA.

6. Purchase metals: Direct your IRA custodian to use the funds to buy the selected metals.

7. Arrange storage: Your metals will be shipped to a secure depository for safekeeping. 

8. Track your investment: Check your account statements and track your investment’s performance.

Moving funds from one IRA to another doesn’t incur any fees as long as it’s a single rollover in a year.

Ask the expert

Rand Millwood

CFP®

Most people conduct a partial rollover, which means they don’t convert all of their IRA to a gold IRA. Typically, there is a desire to hold physical gold as a portion of someone’s retirement savings, so they move a dollar amount or percentage of the current account into the gold IRA and keep the remainder in their current IRA to be invested in typical market-based securities.

Mistakes to avoid

Here are some IRA mistakes to avoid so that you can continue to build your account tax free:

• Indirect rollovers: If you withdraw funds from your IRA and the check is in your name, you have 60 days to roll over the funds before it is considered taxable income. You can avoid this potential pitfall by opting for a direct rollover.

• Exceeding contributions: There are yearly contribution limits for traditional IRAs and gold IRAs. As of 2022, it is $6,000 or $7,000 if you are 50 or older. Anything over this amount is subject to penalties and taxes.

• Converting all at once: Converting a traditional IRA over to a gold IRA is a smart move, but it could trigger additional taxes on your next return. Rather than converting your entire account all at once, you can start with smaller annual conversions to reduce your tax bill. 

Ask the expert

Rand Millwood

CFP®

In the case of the 60-day rollover rule, if you do not redeposit the funds in time you will be taxed on these funds for that tax year plus be hit with the 10% penalty if you are under age 59.5, thus incurring a level of double taxation. Exceeding contributions happens from time to time for several reasons and can be easily remedied by removing funds related to excess contributions. As long as you are doing a direct transfer or if you receive the funds directly and you don’t run afoul of the 60-day rollover rules, there are no issues with converting an entire IRA to a gold IRA. 

How to choose the right gold IRA custodian

Finding the right gold IRA custodian is an important step in securing your investment. Here are a few things to consider before making a selection: 

• Customer reviews: Search for a custodian with positive reviews and high ratings from trusted sources like the Better Business Bureau (BBB).

• Costs: Compare storage fees and management fees to avoid any hidden costs.

• Customer support: Find a custodian that can guide you through the process. 

• Resources: A good custodian offers good customer support as well as educational resources and online market insights.

• Security: Verify that a custodian uses IRS-approved storage facilities. 

Read More

4 Best Gold IRA Companies & Review Accounts

FAQ

What are the tax benefits and considerations of converting an IRA to a gold IRA?

Converting an IRA to a gold IRA can offer several tax benefits, including the potential for tax-deferred growth in a traditional gold IRA and tax-free growth in a Roth gold IRA. 

However, there are also important considerations, such as the initial tax implications of converting a traditional IRA to a Roth gold IRA, potential penalties for early withdrawals, and the need to adhere to IRS regulations regarding the storage and management of gold assets.

Am I required to report my gold IRA conversion to the IRS?

You must report your gold IRA conversion to the IRS, but you don’t always owe taxes on the event.

If you abide by the 60-day rule, you will report your conversion to the IRS on form 1099-R, but you will not owe taxes. If you do not complete the conversion within 60 days, then you will owe taxes on the event.

What is the difference between a transfer and a rollover when converting to a gold IRA?

The difference between a transfer and a rollover when converting to a gold IRA lies in the process and tax implications. 

A transfer involves moving funds directly from one IRA custodian to another without the account holder taking possession of the funds. This process is typically not taxable and can be done multiple times a year. 

A rollover, on the other hand, involves the account holder receiving the funds and then depositing them into the new IRA within 60 days. This process can only be done once per year and may have tax implications if not completed within the specified timeframe.

Can I store the gold from my gold IRA at home?

No, you cannot store the gold from your gold IRA at home. IRS regulations require that the physical gold in a gold IRA be stored in an approved depository. Storing the gold at home would be considered a distribution, which could result in taxes and penalties. 

It is essential to use a qualified custodian to ensure compliance with IRS rules and to protect the tax-advantaged status of your gold IRA.