Bitcoin IRA vs. Gold IRA: Why One Could Be a Smarter Long-Term Play

As economic instability threatens traditional investments, more people are turning to alternative asset IRAs to diversify their portfolios and hedge against dollar depreciation. 

Two options you might explore are gold and crypto IRAs. Start by comparing a bitcoin IRA vs. a gold IRA to decide which aligns better with your investment priorities. In a nutshell, precious metals are a safer choice, while crypto could offer higher returns.

Both crypto and gold IRAs are self-directed IRAs (SDIRAs) that give you plenty of flexibility and control. However, you must comply with IRS guidelines to enjoy the tax advantages of an IRA.

	Gold IRA	Bitcoin IRA
Asset type	Precious metals like gold and silver	Digital currencies like bitcoin and ethereum
Storage	Approved depositories	Approved digital wallets
Stability	Stable	Volatile
Liquidity	Lower	Higher
Hedge investment	Historically proven	Fairly new asset with limited data

Table of Contents

1. What is a gold IRA?
2. What is a bitcoin IRA? 
3. Bitcoin IRA vs. gold IRA 
4. Pros and cons of a bitcoin IRA
5. Pros and cons of a gold IRA 

What is a gold IRA?

A gold IRA is a self-directed IRA that allows you to invest in physical gold, silver, and other precious metals that meet purity requirements (99.5% for gold, 99.9% for silver, and 99.95% for platinum and palladium). Unlike conventional IRAs, which may invest in “paper gold,” a gold IRA holds actual bullion. 

Gold IRAs combine the advantages of investing in physical precious metals with the tax benefits of an IRA. As universally appreciated commodities with intrinsic value, gold and silver appeal to investors seeking a stable store of value. 

Storage and structure

You must store your gold IRA holdings in an approved depository, supervised by an authorized custodian. Well-known gold storage companies include the Delaware Depository, the Texas Precious Metals Depository, and Brink’s Global Services. Home storage is not a valid option for gold SDIRAs. 

Compliance and regulations

Generally, gold IRAs follow the same regulations as all IRAs. These include contribution limits, early withdrawal penalties, and prohibited transactions like self-dealing. 

You may start withdrawing money from your gold IRA when you turn 59½, and you must begin required minimum distributions (RMDs) at 73 unless it’s a Roth IRA.

What is a bitcoin IRA? 

A bitcoin IRA, or crypto IRA, is an SDIRA that enables you to add approved cryptocurrencies to your retirement savings. Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies might appeal to you if you’re a risk-tolerant investor seeking high returns. 

Storage and structure

Like precious metal IRAs, bitcoin IRAs require a licensed custodian. While you decide how much to invest (within contribution limits), the custodian handles your account’s transactions.

Similar to precious metal IRAs, you can’t hold the cryptocurrency in your account yourself. Your custodian will provide an IRS-compliant storage solution, usually a cold storage digital wallet for maximum security. 

Compliance and regulations 

Contributions to and withdrawals from bitcoin IRAs follow the standard guidelines. Specifically:

• With a traditional crypto IRA account, you’re eligible for tax-deductible contributions and tax-deferred asset growth.
• A Roth crypto IRA may qualify you for tax-free withdrawals. 

The IRS views bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies as alternative assets rather than actual currency. As such, these assets need annual valuation for your tax documents. Custodians usually provide fair market value (FMV) for this purpose.

Since crypto is a comparatively new type of asset, tax regulations concerning it continue to evolve. Make sure you keep up with potential changes in tax law and understand how they may influence your investment.

Bitcoin IRA vs. gold IRA 

Between crypto IRAs and gold IRAs, which one is better? The answer depends on your goals and may be different for each investor. 

‼️In addition to doing your research, we strongly recommend consulting a financial advisor before you invest any substantial amounts in precious metals or crypto.

The type of investor best suited for a bitcoin IRA versus a gold IRA depends on the individual investor and their goals regarding either investment. We prefer to hold these investments in a diversified portfolio and never to own too much of a particular investment due to their underlying risks. However, it is prudent to review the considerations mentioned here as well as other sources as part of any investor’s due diligence.

Risk and volatility

Gold is a stable commodity with a rich and ancient history. Although gold prices can fluctuate, this shiny yellow metal has remained a sought-after, universally recognized asset for millennia. Other precious metals, like silver and platinum, are less predictable than gold but also hold intrinsic value.

In contrast, bitcoin has seen sharp peaks and deep lows in its brief history. To date, bitcoin reached its all-time high in December 2024, when one BTC was worth more than $106,000. However, by March 2025, bitcoin had lost approximately a quarter of its value as prices dipped below $80,000.

👉 Takeaway: While crypto attracts adventurous investors, gold makes more sense for those who seek a secure asset.

Both investment opportunities provide benefits to client portfolios but need to be weighed with the client’s goals. What are the diversification benefits of adding (or not adding) either of these investments? Gold is more widely used for diversification purposes, but bitcoin has remained more speculative and volatile.

Storage and security

Gold deposits in IRAs ship to IRS-compliant depositories with world-class security. Armed personnel, 24/7 surveillance, biometric scanners, and comprehensive insurance keep your investment safe. You don’t need to worry about hacking.

Approved digital wallets for crypto storage are also safe, but cybersecurity risks still exist. Malware can steal keys if you ever connect a cold storage wallet to a hacked computer. Cybercriminals could also compromise storage hardware before use.

👉 Takeaway: Both gold and crypto IRAs offer secure storage options, but gold’s physical security is more straightforward, while crypto carries some cybersecurity risks you must manage carefully.

Fees and costs

Gold IRA costs include setup, storage, and custodian fees. You’ll also cover dealer markups when you purchase bullion. If you take possession of the bullion when you retire, you may pay a one-time delivery fee. 

With a bitcoin IRA, you’ll likewise pay setup, storage, custodian, and trading fees. You may also pay liquidation costs if you decide to sell your holdings.  

Some precious metal depositories charge percentage-based fees on gold storage and insurance. In this case, you’d pay more as your holdings grow (up to a maximum cap). Bitcoin custodians usually charge a flat storage fee.

👉 Takeaway: Every precious metal and crypto IRA provider has a different fee structure, so compare options to choose a competitively priced plan.

Liquidity

Bitcoin is one of the most liquid investment assets. Global crypto exchanges operate 24/7, and you can quickly turn your holdings into cash. Transactions only take minutes and don’t require an intermediary. 

Gold is somewhat less liquid. To sell your gold holdings, you’ll need to contact your custodian and tell them you plan to sell some of your bullion. Then you’ll need to find a dealer (your custodian may be able to assist with this). 

Transactions also involve paperwork and shipping. The entire process could take a few days to a couple of weeks. Moreover, you can only trade during exchanges’ business hours.

👉 Takeaway: Bitcoin is far easier to buy and sell at any time, while gold requires a more involved process. This makes it less liquid, but it remains a valuable long-term asset.

Wealth protection

Investors have traditionally turned to gold as a safe-haven asset during economic or geopolitical shifts. Gold’s value tends to rise as fiat currencies depreciate, making it a dependable store of wealth during high inflation. Moreover, as a tangible asset with intrinsic worth, securely stored gold isn’t vulnerable to counterparty risk. 

Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies offer another angle of wealth protection. Since bitcoin is a decentralized, global asset operating within a peer-to-peer system, it may reduce reliance on central banks and has high inflation-resistance potential. Bitcoin’s main drawbacks are its high volatility and the potential for future regulations that could reduce the value of crypto assets.

👉 Takeaway: Gold has a long history as a haven during economic instability, while bitcoin offers potential inflation resistance but comes with more uncertainty and volatility.

Tax implications

Largely, gold and bitcoin IRAs, both self-directed IRAs, follow the same tax rules. However, some differences apply. 

For instance, when you withdraw gold from an IRA, you pay taxes on it as regular income. Meanwhile, selling cryptocurrency may be subject to capital gains tax. 

The tax regulations of gold IRAs are established and predictable since gold is a traditional asset. Crypto IRA taxation rules are still evolving. If you aren’t sure how taxes work for your SDIRA, please talk to a professional rather than risk penalties.

👉 Takeaway: Both gold and crypto IRAs follow standard tax rules, but gold taxation is more established, whereas crypto tax regulations continue to evolve—making professional guidance essential.

Who is it best for?

Overall, a bitcoin IRA can be a lucrative option for those who are interested in high-return assets with rapid growth potential and who can handle bitcoin’s dramatic price swings. Often, these are growth-oriented, tech-savvy investors who believe in the future of cryptocurrency. 

A gold IRA may be a better choice for conservative investors seeking a stable asset that preserves its value during periods of inflation and market downturns. People who decide to invest in gold typically prioritize a safe retirement and lean toward tangible assets.

Of course, you don’t necessarily have to choose between gold and bitcoin. If you have the investment capacity, you could open a gold IRA and a bitcoin IRA for a well-balanced portfolio. Our top choice for an IRA provider that will allow you to buy precious metals and crypto in the same account is iTrustCapital.

👉 Takeaway: Bitcoin IRAs suit risk-tolerant investors seeking high growth potential, while gold IRAs are ideal for those prioritizing stability. Holding both assets in a diversified portfolio can provide a balanced approach.

Pros and cons of a bitcoin IRA

A bitcoin IRA may yield impressive returns and help you achieve financial independence during retirement. However, market crashes and potential unfavorable regulations could jeopardize your holdings. 

Pros

• High return potentialStability

  Bitcoin has shown massive growth capacity, which gold and other precious metals can’t match. While it has experienced some sharp downturns, it has also bounced back impressively.

• Portability and liquidity

  As a digital asset, bitcoin is easily accessible and transferable. Crypto exchanges offer lightning-fast trading, while finding a buyer for precious metals could take time.

• Independence and decentralization

  Since cryptocurrency works independently of traditional systems, central bank policies don’t affect it, and the government can’t seize it. Gold ownership, on the other hand, was subject to restrictions in the past.

Cons

• Volatility

  Bitcoin prices are a rollercoaster ride. For instance, bitcoin crashed during the COVID pandemic, losing about 60% of its value from February to March 2020. Bitcoin’s instability can be a major problem if its value drops just when you must start making withdrawals from your IRA.

• Unpredictable regulations

  Precious metal IRAs follow established regulations, while crypto IRA laws are still evolving, which could affect your retirement assets.

• Cybersecurity risks

  Cold storage crypto wallets are highly secure, but bitcoin investments could still fall prey to exchange failures or hacking. Dealing in physical gold doesn’t involve these risks.

Read More

Best Crypto IRAs

Pros and cons of a gold IRA 

Gold IRAs are super dependable and can help preserve wealth during financial downturns. However, physical gold generates much lower returns than bitcoin and may involve considerable storage fees.

Pros

• Stability

  Gold is an established, reliable asset. Its prices may fluctuate but have historically risen over time, making it a safer option for retirement compared to crypto.

• Hedge against inflation

  Gold tends to preserve its worth during inflation and economic crises. It could protect your wealth if the market enters a rough period when you start taking distributions from your IRA.

• Clear regulations

  Gold IRAs work under clear, predictable regulations, so they’re less likely to run into compliance issues or negative tax implications than crypto IRAs.

Cons

• Low growth potential

  Compared to bitcoin, gold appreciates slowly. It’s more effective as a store of value than as a vehicle for wealth growth.

• Storage costs

  Unlike bitcoin and other digital assets, gold bullion needs an approved physical depository. Keeping a large amount of gold may mean paying high custodial, insurance, and storage fees.

• Lower liquidity

  If you want to liquidate part of your gold IRA, you’ll need to find a buyer and act through your custodian. This process could be inconvenient if you need to convert bullion into cash fast.

Read More

Best Gold IRAs