Many or all of the companies featured provide compensation to LendEDU. These commissions are how we maintain our free service for consumers. Compensation, along with hours of in-depth editorial research, determines where & how companies appear on our site.
Note: Petplan has rebranded to FetchPet. The information below is still accurate as the product itself has not changed.
Pet insurance is a good way to offset any unexpected medical costs you may incur as a pet owner. If your animal is injured, sick, or requires diagnostic testing, insurance can cover a portion or even all of the costs of these services, as long as you’ve met your annual deductible.
Petplan and Healthy Paws are just two of the pet health insurance providers you can choose from. Having trouble deciding which one is best for your pet and finances? This Petplan vs. Healthy Paws pet insurance comparison can help.
In this comparison:
Healthy Paws vs Petplan: What’s offered?
|Benefit Limit||Unlimited||$2,500 – Unlimited|
|Reimbursement||50% – 90%||Up to 90%|
|Deductible||$100 – $1,000||$250 – $1,000|
|Pets Covered||Dogs and Cats||Dogs and Cats|
LendEDU Rating: 4.2/5
Healthy Paws also offers insurance for cats and dogs, with unlimited maximums for all covered services. Those include things like treatment for hereditary conditions and congenital conditions, alternative therapies (acupuncture and chiropractic care), and even hip dysplasia coverage for pets under age 6.
LendEDU Rating: 4.8/5
Petplan offers insurance plans for both cats and dogs. What sets the insurer apart from other options is its coverage of non-routine dental work (extractions, root canals, etc.) and behavioral treatments. Unlike other insurers, Petplan has no upper age limit for coverage, though it does say reimbursements may be more limited for animals over 10 years old.
Healthy Paws vs. Petplan: Coverage comparison
|Plan Effective Date||Next day||Next day|
|Waiting Period for Injury/Illness||15 days||15 days|
|Age Limits||6 weeks to 14 years*||6 weeks+|
|Wellness & Routine Coverage||No||No|
|Non-Routine Dental Work||No||Yes|
|Euthanasia, Burial, & Cremation||No||No|
|Behavioral Disorder Coverage||No||Yes|
|Choose Your Veterinarian||Yes||Yes|
|Visit Provider||View Rates||View Rates|
*This upper-age limit is only enforced for new enrollments. If your pet was enrolled before the age of 15, it will remain eligible.
Healthy Paws vs. Petplan: Which is right for you?
Most pet insurance providers have similar insurance policies, with only slight differences in coverage and costs. If you’re finding it difficult to discern which insurer might be best for your animal’s needs, the scenarios below can help guide you.
If you want fast reimbursement
If getting reimbursed for your vet bills fast is your ultimate goal, Healthy Paws is likely your best bet. The insurer says it pays the majority of its claims out within 10 days. Petplan has a longer window for payouts at 30 days.
If you want low deductibles
Of the two insurers, Healthy Paws offers the lower deductibles. Deductibles start at $100 per year, compared to $250 for Petplan’s lowest-deductible option
If you have an older pet
Many pet insurance companies have age limits in place. Medical costs tend to increase as animals age. While Healthy Paws is one such insurer (it won’t cover animals past 14 years if not enrolled prior to the pet turning that page), Petplan does not have an age maximum for coverage.
If you want behavioral coverage
Behavioral issues like digging, soiling the carpet, and even separation anxiety can be difficult and expensive to treat. Though most insurers do not offer coverage for these types of treatments (Healthy Paws included), Petplan does. The insurer’s plans include up to $1,000 in annual coverage toward behavioral therapies.
If you want the most financial protection
Healthy Paws plans have no caps or maximums (even the lowest-cost plans). There are no per-incident limits and no annual or lifetime caps either. This could equate to significant savings should your pet develop a serious medical condition or need multiple surgeries or treatments. While Petplan does offer an annual unlimited coverage option, it’s only available on the highest-cost plan—not across the board, as with Healthy Paws’ options.
Where to find other pet insurance alternatives
There are dozens of pet insurance companies on the market, so make sure to shop around if you want the best deal. If you’re looking for preventative coverage, you might also consider a pet wellness plan. These cover veterinary bills for things like vaccinations, heartworm medication, and more. Check out our guide to the best pet insurance companies to see all your options.
How we rated Healthy Paws and Petplan
Our Healthy Paws and Petplan scores were based on the weighted average of multiple data points, including waiting periods, benefit limits, customer reviews, and more.
Author: Aly Yale